Skip to main content

The Isle of Skye Part 5 - An Sithean Part 2






NB: I'm fully aware this kind of conjecture is largely pointless without any hard facts to back it up.  So if you're not into that kind of thing then sorry! But I find it fun, and it helps build my own excitement about a stone trip, not to mention means I'm more prepared when I arrive and start looking for these stones.


Flag is pretty much the location of An Sithean, just north of the road heading south out of Broadford. Co-ordinates from megalithic website 




The above series of screenshots were taken from the "Streetview" function of Google maps at the An Sithean location. Starting from the west (side), the image series continues as if one is travelling currently moving east, heading towards Broadford.

I've made the following "assumptions" here:

1. The lifting stones of An Sithean still exist.
   - They've not been lost, destroyed, damaged by road construction, etc

2. They're on the north side of the road.
   - Peter Martin said the stones were lifted on the roadside, so whilst not conclusive on which side, I've had a quick scan on the street view of both sides and found little that looks promising on the south side. Which isn't to say a physical look on the south side wouldn't be worth it.

3. The stones were fairly near/"below" An Sithean itself.


4. Addendum to 1, the above streetview images were captured by a Google car in 2011. So it's fingers crossed that the stones existed in 2011, and still exist now, 8 years later in the same spots-ish. Google also has a street view image of the area in 2009, and the stones I'm looking at are still in the same spots.

5. The road hasn't changed that much - but given we're talking about late 19th century to now, that's not an easy given I don't feel?
    - On one hand you'd be unable to move the road much up the hill due to it's contours, and creating a road on an existing path/road would seem the most sensible option. For what is probably the most dull eccentric facs I've ever looked for, the B8083 (the road we're looking at here,) was originally an unclassified route, and became the A881 in the late 1920s, becoming the B8083 in 1995. So it was certainly pretty much the same road I presume in the early 20th century.

Now that's out the way, I've got one more consideration. Knowing that there is sites of archaeological significance at An Sithean, the handful of hut circle remains as listed at Canmore. Canmore lists three on the South side of the road, one on the north side. I've struggled to work out for sure, but it looks like the roughly rectangular arrangement of stones seen in the above images, particularly in image 3, left hand side of the photo, is the hut circle on the north side of the road. I only mention this as whilst there's the possibility that the stones lifted at An Sithean were indeed stones from these ruins, any stone identified for lifting should most definitely not be part of any existing remains to preserve these sites.

Really, that was all a long way to say I feel that if there's any way to use street view to look for these lifting stones, it might be the stones around the path most visible in the final two images. Two  are above the path both looking pretty angular in shape, and one the otherside which looks a little blockier.

My one concern about these stones being a good target for a lift to continue the tradition of lifting at this site, is there size - to my eyes they don't look that large or that heavy. Lots of the western Island stones are fairly heavy, especially in North Uist, and as we've already seen in Skye stones like Clach Mhor Mhic Crimmion are large. I've spent some time looking to see if there is any way of figuring out object sizes from Google street view, but it seems the answer is no. If you know any different please let me know! Here's a comparison image I've taken from Google street view of the Bodach Craigh Fianna at Glen Lyon.

If you start at the centre of the 'X' on the road, travel towards the fence on the RHS of the image, the stone nearest to the fence is the plinth, and just to the right/above it is the lifting stone, weighing in at 127kg/300lb whilst not being a "huge" stone in size.

I'm not going to be bringing any weighing equipment with me to Skye, so time will tell.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New Scotland, New Stones - Gaelic Strength Culture Across The Atlantic

Gaelic Strength Culture Across The Atlantic Relevant geography update if you're like me and relatively unfamiliar with Canada other than that Toronto is in the east and Vancouver in the west. Nova Scotia is a province (equivalent of county if you're also from the U.K) and covers all the yellow bits in the image from Wikipedia. Cape Breton is part of that, and is the bit on the upper right corner of the image - shaped a bit like a leaf split in two. Right now I had planned to be finishing off the final installment on Skye, as my trip to the Misty Isle looms. I was researching further for Clach Mhor Na Saothraich, and came across a website called "Cape Breton's Magazine"  and a scanned image from page 26 of "D.N. MacLennan's History of Grand River", which seems to be an ongoing (I think? by that I mean, was ongoing too) published article in a newspaper. The date on the page suggests the article is from 1977.   Grand River is a town on the s...

Norge - Pinch Stones. Proposal Stones, Prodigious Stones and Penis Stones in Norway - Part 1

Stone Lifting in Norway Inspired by Ryan Stewart, Nic Whalen and Mark Prows' recently stone lifting tour of Sweden (and Iceland before that), I got all distracted from my Skye research and spent far too long going down the rabbit hole of Norway. You could probably throw a dart at a map of the world, blindfolded, and still hit a country that has a history of stone lifting to some degree, and Norway seemed a likely candidate for having a good number with Sweden clearly having a rich stone history. This blog isn't intended to be a complete document on all of Norway and stones - I wouldn't ever claim to be able to write such, nor is it huge amount of work. It's what I managed to find with a handful of spare hours and a few tussles with Google translate. On a similar vein, I won't sadly be able to make a trip to Norway any time too soon, so don't plan on doing any more follow up work to this post in the near future. If anyone else knows more or plans to do furt...

Taransay - a break from Skye

Taransay Why did the ocean floor blush? Because it saw the sea-weed. As I got bogged down into details of the further Skye stones and try get things into some sort of comprehensible readable, (or even useful) order, I thought I'd take a break from scouring for obscure references and tidbits of information on those stones, and write about some others on my list. Taransay is the largest uninhabited island in Scotland, which makes you think it'd be pretty big, but no - a whopping 5.7sq miles in area. Home to the Celts since at least 300 AD, later invaded by Vikings, and then later a farming island, it was abandoned in 1941 for a short while, by 1961 there was one family living there who moved out in 1974. An 1841 census had 120~ people living on the island - so it's always been pretty quiet! Other than a brief stint in 2000 when the UK tv channel 4 filmed "Castaway" there there has been no real human habitation to speak of since - beside the odd tour...